The Truth About “Secret” Tax Shelter Trusts - What the IRS Really Says
- Chris Johnsen
- 10 minutes ago
- 6 min read
Modern digital marketing enables the distribution of promotional content that promises hidden tax avoidance techniques through complex legal methods.
These advertising campaigns use complex trust arrangements along with technical legal terminology to create an impression of authenticity.
Johnsen Law encounters numerous clients who were exposed to misleading social media promotions about these legal structures through their business employment and estate planning practice. This article will describe what tax shelter trusts truly represent while explaining their ineffective nature and how the IRS views these structures.
This article also provides an overview of how these structures are marketed and their problems and it teaches readers how to detect deceptive online tax planning advice.
What Are These “Secret” Trusts?
Deceptive Terminology and Complex Acronyms
These trusts receive their names from their creators who aim to establish legitimacy and exclusivity through sophisticated terminology. Various legal structures are known as non-grantor irrevocable complex discretionary spendthrift trust, capital gains deferred trust, business trust and terms such as super vehicle or five-point trust. The structures are frequently shortened through complex acronyms which include NICDST and DDSCINT to create an impression that these advanced tax strategies belong to a small group of experts.
The Misleading Claim of Tax-Exempt Principal
The trust promoters state that when income goes into the trust principal or corpus it becomes exempt from federal income taxation. The Internal Revenue Code Section 643 serves as their basis for their claims through the use of technical terminology. The materials seem realistic because they target high-net-worth individuals who seek to minimize their tax obligations. The structures utilize real trust types but their promotional methods and advertising statements are deceptive and incorrect.
How Promoters Misinterpret the Law
The Internal Revenue Code Section 643 has a valid role in trust taxation though the schemes use it in a misleading fashion.
Misunderstanding Distributable Net Income (DNI) vs. Taxable Income
According to Section 643 of the Internal Revenue Code DNI stands for distributable net income. The two terms 'taxable income' and 'distributable net income' have distinct meanings even though some promoters treat them as equivalent. The amount of income that can be deducted from trust taxes depends on DNI for distribution to beneficiaries. The beneficiaries receive taxable income amounts through their personal returns which depend on this determination.
The False Claim of Income Disappearing from Taxation
Promoters select particular subsections from Section 643 to explain how capital gains and extraordinary dividends affect DNI calculations. The promoters use this interpretation to argue that income allocated to the corpus results in its disappearance from taxable income. This is false.
The tax rules found in these subsections help determine what income belongs to DNI calculations but they do not decide whether income gets taxed or not. All income generated by the trust requires reporting and tax assessment through either trust-level taxation or beneficiary-level taxation. The tax system has no authorized method which would allow income to completely escape taxation.
The IRS’s Official Position
The IRS has officially clarified its stance regarding these trust structures through public statements.
DNI Framework: Determining Trust vs. Beneficiary Taxation
According to the IRS, the distributable net income framework exists to separate trust and beneficiary taxation responsibilities. The tax framework allows trusts to claim deductions and beneficiaries to report income but it does not create a way to avoid paying taxes.
All trust income stemming from rental payments dividends and capital gains must undergo taxation according to the IRS. The beneficiary must pay taxes when the trust distributes income to them. The trust becomes responsible for paying taxes when it decides to maintain the income within its structure. The tax system provides no opportunity to escape taxation through any middle ground.
Heightened Scrutiny of Tax Shelter Trust Arrangements
The IRS has told its auditors to specifically look for these types of arrangements. Trusts marketed as “non-grantor irrevocable complex discretionary spendthrift trusts” or similar will be closely scrutinized. Audits by the IRS check that income is correctly reported and capital gains or extraordinary dividends are allocated in a manner that does not break established tax rules.
Why These Trusts Don’t Work for Tax Avoidance
All the marketing and legalese aside, these trusts do not deliver the main benefit they promise: the avoidance of tax liability. The IRS has made it clear that income must be reported and taxed whether it is by the trust or the beneficiaries.
The Financial and Legal Risks for Clients
Promoters of these schemes usually charge very high fees—sometimes as much as $50,000—for drafting the trust documents and “educating” the client on how to use them. These costs are often presented as needed to access this “elite” tax-saving strategy, but in reality, clients are being deceived into believing that a legal work around exists where none does.
Some clients who buy these trusts end up paying for wasted money and time and also face legal and financial problems from IRS audits. The penalties for not reporting correctly or not filing properly can be very high and in extreme cases criminal liability can arise if the arrangement is deemed to be fraudulent.
How to Protect Yourself
The best protection against misinformation is education.
The Importance of Education and Consulting Licensed Professionals
Take the time to read the IRS’s official rulings and guidance. These documents are available to the public and are written for transparency. If you are thinking of a complex trust structure, consult with a licensed and experienced tax professional or attorney.
Be very careful of any financial plan that claims you can avoid paying any taxes. Legal tax planning strategies can reduce your tax burden but they cannot eliminate it. Any strategy which states you can earn income without paying taxes should immediately set off warning bells.
Detecting Warning Signs in Tax Avoidance Claims
Ask tough questions. Demand citations from reputable sources. And if someone is not able or willing to explain a tax strategy in terms you can understand, that’s often a sign that the strategy itself may be questionable.
Looking Ahead: Trust Transparency Over Magic Bullets
These promoted trust structures do not provide a legal way to avoid paying taxes even though you may have seen them on social media or heard them in glossy presentations. The IRS is well aware of these schemes and is currently auditing and pursuing those who use them. If you are serious about estate planning and tax efficiency, there are legitimate strategies available—but none of them are “magic bullets.”
The IRS's Awareness and Pursuit of Tax Evasion Schemes
At Johnsen Law, we help clients with the complexities of trust law, tax planning, and asset protection in a transparent and legally sound way. If you have encountered one of these schemes and want a second opinion, or if you just want to explore legal ways to minimize your tax liability, our attorneys are here to help. If something sounds too good to be true, especially when it comes to taxes, it probably is.
Additional Resources
Seeking Reliable Legal and Tax Advice
You can read more in the IRS’s official publications or contact Johnsen Law for reliable legal advice. Our team is prepared to assist you in making decisions that safeguard your wealth, your family, and your future.
Would you like me to find the specific IRS guidance on abusive trust tax evasion schemes?
Thank you for reading! Share this useful information with others who would benefit from it.
Subscribe to our Email Notifications list. By subscribing to our email list you will be sure to get a notification about our next article that is posted here on JohnsenLaw.com/blog
along with other special updates.
You can connect with our skilled Texas Business Attorneys by calling (832) 786-8645 or reaching out to us here to set up a consultation.
